While not a mainstream Hindi movie, I thought I’d include a review here that I did a few months back of Deepa Mehta’s most recent film.

Water, the final film in director Deepa Mehta’s trilogy of the elements, proves to moviegoers that good things can come to those who wait.
The history of the making of the film is itself an epic saga. It took a total of seven years to bring the movie to screen. In 2000, just two days into filming in Varanasi, under the complaint that Mehta’s film was casting India and Hinduism in an unflattering light, violent protests, destruction of the sets and death threats by political and religious groups shut the production down. Four years later, after a patchwork of funding and a new cast were lined up, filming began again, this time in Sri Lanka, under an innocuous false title and tight secrecy. Mehta can consider herself vindicated, as the film was selected to open the Toronto International Film festival last September and has been garnering rave reviews since.
The movie opens with the main character, the eight-year-old girl, Chuyia, sitting in the back of a cart, chomping happily on sugar cane and being chastised for tickling the feet of the man stretched out next to her. We learn that the year is 1938, she is a child bride and her husband is dying. Uncomprehending and unperturbed, she sits blankly in the next scene while the now deceased man is cremated in Varanasi and her long, thick hair is shorn. Under the dark of night, her parents deposit her at a widows’ residence just off the banks of the Ganges, setting in motion a chain of events that leaves its mark on many lives, just as Gandhi’s influence at that time is having an effect across India.
When faced with the dire penury and restrictions the widows endure, the distraught child rebels. Some of the women are touched by her and take pity on her. Shakuntala (played by Seema Biswas, in the role that was to have been Shabana Azmi’s) is stern but kind, and she becomes a mother of sorts to Chuyia. Living upstairs, apart from the others, is Kalyani, played by the ethereal beauty, Lisa Ray, who has been allowed to keep her hair long because she is prostituted to wealthy clients across the river. She plays older sister to Chuyia, and her small garret serves as a refuge. The ashram is ruled by Madhumati – the physically imposing madam of the house (literally) – who can only see Kalyani as a unique revenue source. When she learns of Kalyani’s love for a young man, she does everything she can to thwart the union, first cutting off her hair, and then locking her up.
The love interest, Narayan, is played by John Abraham, who Mehta says she chose for his eyes and voice, and “because he could convey idealism and not be a wimp.” Narayan is a sensitive, thoughtful law graduate excited by the teachings of Gandhi. He questions everything that he cannot make sense of or accept: British rule in India, his mother’s wish that he marry soon just because of his age, and the treatment of widows. Narayan falls in love and is prepared to flaunt convention and his mother’s opposition to be with Kalyani, just as several threads of the story come together, with tragic results.
Of the three films in the trilogy, this is the strongest and most complete. While Shabana Azmi and Nandita Das (who is still not on speaking terms with Mehta) would likely have performed well, we are fortunate to witness Seema Biswas shine in a role that she has made her own.
On the occasion of Fox Searchlight Pictures release of Water in the U.S., Deepa Mehta was in New York for interviews, where she said the most challenging role to cast was Chuyia. She looked at 80 young girls in Mumbai, Delhi and Kolkata, but found that “most have been so influenced by Bollywood and the soaps they have unconsciously imbibed mannerisms that are so over-the-top and I thought it would be real work to undo that.” Sarala, the young actor chosen, comes from a small town near Colombo. Speaking only Sinhala, she learned her lines and direction through translation and sign language.
Lisa Ray and John Abraham are unexpectedly solid in their roles. Also in New York to promote the film, Lisa Ray commented that, while she has no intention of pursuing work in Bollywood movies, working with Abraham was “a revelation” and that she would have to, on occasion, stifle a laugh while still on camera because her co-star would trip on his dhoti upon exiting the scene.
The dialogue in Water is pared down and not as speechy as in Fire and Earth. Mehta herself admits it was too lengthy in the original script.
The absence and appearance of color weave in and out through the film. The widows’ residence is grey and bleak, emphasized even more by the ghostly residents, semi-catatonic in their grubby white saris and shorn heads. A riotously bright parrot and black puppy, two creatures not bound by man’s use of religion, provide vivid contrast to the bloodless lives of the virtual shut-ins. Because our eyes become accustomed to the visual monotony of the household, the scene of the puppy Kaalu running through the Varanasi lanes, dashing by chickens and through dry red peppers, the brilliance of the clothes worn by a mother and young daughter giving alms at the temple, Chuyia’s Krishna costume and the colored powders as the widows celebrate Holi, all explode on the screen like a flash flood in a desert. Even Narayan asks Kalyani about her would-be new life: “What is the first color you will wear?”

When talking about being a Toronto resident for over 30 years and returning often to India to make the movies that she does, Mehta credits being an Indo-Canadian, saying that “In Canada we really are a multi-cultural society, there is no melting pot and that is why I never felt that I had to leave my Indianness behind.” At the same time as the movie’s release in the U.S., Newmarket Press has just published Shooting Water: A Memoir of Second Chances, Family and Filmmaking by Devyani Saltzman, Deepa Mehta’s daughter. The twenty-something Oxford grad narrates the deep impact that her parents’ divorce, and choice to live with her father, had on her parents and herself in the past 15 years, and how, working in India and Sri Lanka as a member of the Water crew, allowed her a chance to rebuild her ties with her mother.










